Attention, listeners, we have a first! Paul and Erika welcome not only their first male guest...they welcome their first TWO male guests! Scott and Pete from Movies That Made Us Gay (@mtmug on Instagram) join for the first spooky movie of the year: camp classic Elvira, Mistress of the Dark. What is edible underwear made out of? Is Hamburger Helper an aphrodisiac? And most importantly, what does Edie McClurg’s hair taste like? All this and more!
-Want to watch the unaired Elvira sitcom pilot? Why wouldn’t you! Here you go.